The Final Appeal: Nude Body Scanners Petition Filed in Supreme Court

TSA Case Back to Supreme CourtI started this blog about 4.5 years ago with a simple, 5-page complaint stating that imaging my body as a condition of flying violates my rights. The case was filed in a U.S. District Court, then went to a U.S. Court of Appeals, then denied a U.S. Supreme Court review, then back to the Court of Appeals, and now, back to the Supreme Court. If they refuse to hear my case, litigation around the body scanners is over: my case can’t proceed and a challenge from anyone else would be time-barred. If they accept it, it will be a few more years before anything is final, as we work through the Supreme Court arguments process and then (hopefully) end up back in the Court of Appeals. In the meantime, of course, the government is free to continue to abuse our rights.

The petition is fairly simple and really brings up only two issues:

  1. The government had successfully argued that since things bounced around between courts as described above, by the time my case finally got to the right place, it was too late to hear the claim. One should not lose their right to challenge the constitutionality of government policies simply because there was a dispute as to the court to hear the claim, especially since in this case, the policy was issued in secret and therefore there was no way to determine the proper court in advance.
  2. The courts below never allowed me any opportunity for discovery, or any other fact-gathering process, and so they basically decided the case based on the government’s cherry-picked reasons as to why the body scanners are necessary and effective. This one-sided process doesn’t meet due process requirements.

Let’s see if the high court wants to accomplish something!

Corbett v. TSA – Petition for Certiorari

10 thoughts on “The Final Appeal: Nude Body Scanners Petition Filed in Supreme Court

Add yours

  1. No member of the Appeals Court or the Supreme Court is going to allow themsleves to be molested as pre-requisite to traveling on a comercial airline. The FedGov is F a s c i s t .

  2. We are a nation of privileges, not a nation of laws, with Government controlling who gets the privileges and who doesn’t.

  3. Damn, John is there anyway you can think of for getting more publicity? Perhaps some news station? This is important.

  4. Posted on the TSA Watch facebook feed:

    Subject: TSAWatch Comment John Corbetts last chance at suing tsa for body scanners and pat downs

    Message Body:
    Hello Mr. Evan [Cutler],

    Most people are unaware that John Corbett has the last remaining lawsuit against the TSA scanners and pat-downs. If the government rejects his request all other lawsuits against the TSA scanners and pat-downs will be time barred. The title of his blog about this is called:

    The Final Appeal: Nude Body Scanners Petition Filed In Supreme Court…

    If you are interested, can you get the word out about this considering this is the last chance for a lawsuit agains the scanners and pat downs? Thank you for your time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: