The TSA has been tasked with finding “weapons, exposives, and incendiaries” and preventing them from making their way onto airplanes. See 49 CFR § 1540.5 (“Screening function means the inspection of individuals and property for weapons, explosives, and incendiaries.”) and ad nauseum court decisions. To that extent, the TSA can lawfully conduct an “administrative search” for only that purpose. This means that if they’re searching in a way that is intended to find evidence of other unrelated crimes (most often, finding small quantities of drugs), they’ve exceeded their authority and are conducting an unconstitutional search with neither consent nor warrant. Courts have repeatedly slapped down evidence found by TSA searches not aimed at finding WEI as inadmissable.
Last week, the government filed a motion to dismiss my lawsuit relating to them illegally detaining me for refusing to let them grope me (now the fourth motion to dismiss so far in this case, none so far yet granted). Part of the suit was that while detaining me, the TSA went through every inch of my bags, including reading my books, credit cards, and anything else that had print on it. Naturally, this offers no value to the search for WEI, but you could see on their faces that they were so upset that someone would dare to say no to being groped that they wanted to find evidence of any crime just to “show me what happens” when people argue with their authoritah.
This motion to dismiss stated that the TSA has the right to search bags not only for WEI, but also for “identification media.” They reason that a terrorist might be using a fake ID, and therefore if they can find a fake ID in your bag, they might stop a terrorist from boarding an airplane.
This term (“identificaiton media”) is not defined in their motion or in their internal policy that discusses it. At the least, they claim ID cards, credit cards, and the like are covered. What about a bank statement, insurance bill, or official letter? Often times a DMV will ask for something along those lines as proof of your identification. How about those prescription bottles? Everything has your name on it and nothing looks “suspicious” about the pills inside, yeah? What about every other document? Might have to read it to make sure it’s not a bank statement, bill, official letter, etc. What about turning on your iPhone to see what name shows up in there? You laptop will presumably identify you and all your e-mail “aliases,” right? And what are you doing with that “suspicious” amount of cash? A terrorist might deal in cash, after all.
Make no mistake: the TSA will use this policy to justify any search of your belongings, including checking out the pictures of your wife on your cell phone, “investigating” your credit cards and bank accounts (stealing iPads was so last year, bank fraud is the new thing), and doing whatever they can to find evidence of any impropriety whatsoever, at which point the police are called. At that point, if you forgot to pay that traffic ticket, you forgot about the half-gram of medicinal marijuana you left in your pants pocket, or if you’re just generally pissed off about your rights being shredded (or in TSA parlance, “disorderly” and “interfereing with checkpoint screening”), you’re going to jail.
All this, ladies and gentlemen, is to ensure compliance. Don’t want to be groped? You better go through this radiation machine and let us take a nude picture. Don’t want the TSA up in your iPhone? They only save that search for the “troublemakers.” Just do what you’re told, don’t argue, and the TSA may let you pass.
This is truly “papers, please” — it can happen now on any mode of transportation, and if the search can include taking nude pictures of our bodies, touching our genitals, and reading our documents, there is truly no limit left on these searches. All that’s left are full strip searches and literally putting their fingers inside of us — oh wait, both have happened time and time again (from the last link: “I sobbed even louder as the woman, FOUR TIMES, stuck the side of her gloved hand INTO my vagina, through my pants. Between my labia.”). There should be no doubt left that this is not “for our safety.”
As a glimmer of hope, this “identification media” reasoning has already been declared unconstitutional by a federal judge! In US v. Fofana, the TSA had a man arrested after going through his bags and finding additional passports, then reading the passports and determining that they were fake. There was no possiblity that reading the passports would have resulted in discovering a bomb, and the TSA used the same “could have been someone other than the person he claimed to be” justification. U.S. District Judge Algenon L. Marbley suppressed the evidence, noting that the TSA “went beyond the permissible purpose of detecting weapons and explosives and was instead motivated by a desire to uncover contraband evidencing ordinary criminal wrongdoing.” However, the TSA apparently feels it can ignore the courts, as it did in the EPIC case.
Corbett v. TSA – Motion to Dismiss IV
Corbett v. TSA – Motion to Dismiss IV (Memorandum in Support)
TSA ignores everyone. The Courts, the Congress, and anyone who opposes them.
The Airlines a l l o w them to do it. The Airlines betray commercial ticket-holders.
Let the Airlines go bankrupt. Collpase the entire industry. ABOLISH T.S.A.
What control could the airlines possibly exert over the TSA? The TSA operates with government blessing – it doesn’t remotely answer to the airlines. In fact, the airlines answer to the TSA. The aviation industry as a whole is at the mercy of these thugs – please don’t blame the victim here.
I went to the TSA’s advisory committee meeting in May, which is composed entirely of representatives of the industry. Not one of them brought up privacy. The airlines can do a lot to lobby the government, but choose not to.
so, what is recommended if they try to examine my iphone, especially when I am recording them with it? advise them that is outside the scope of the WEI and therefore requires a warrant? (Personally, I believe the WHOLE security theater thing requires a warrant, and have refused to fly until they comply with the 4th Amendment)
If it were me, I would forcibly stop them from going through my electronic media. Send me to jail if you must, but my documents are off-limits.
Totally agree with esgatch. The airlines are complicit. When are people going to get this through their heads??
The airlines are complicit. They are treating people like shit, and people just lick it up. They are playing them for fools.
Otherwise, bravo, Jon. You are an eternal hero.
Readheadwrit – There’s an app called TapIn that might suit your needs if it can continue recording while the phone is locked. It uploads live so there’s no file that they can delete and you get a recording of the whole time they’re trying to search the phone. Start recording, enter Checkpoint Charlie, and let the blue-shirted domestic terrorists have at it.
Welcome to the New and Improved America 2.0; the Police State perfected.
Thank you 🙂
Isn’t there at least one brave soul in Congress to try and stop this TSA madness??
lol all you butt hurt liberals… aww wahhhhhh
lol… sorry, I’m conservative/libertarian. It doesn’t require a left or right slant to stand up to government thuggery. 🙂
youre a complete idiot and have no full grasp of what the tsa’s responsibilities consist of. as of 9/11 the rules have change and if youre unhappy with them then take it up wit the terrorists.
Actually, the Constitution did not change since 9/11, and I will take it up with those who try to change it.
I was just arrested for talking on my phone with my pregnant wife while in the global entry area.
I was told to get off the phone and I said no, that there were no signs posted, and that I was going to finish this call with my pregnant wife.
They then said I had to comply. I turned my back and kept talking.
Next thing? I’m in hand cuffs and sent to a detention room.
I have a TS clearance, current Special Forces (12 years), never been arrested.
I feel my right to speech was violated when placed under arrest. I could see them telling me I wouldn’t be allowed further till off my phone so they could talk to me without distraction, but arresting me?
No meranda rights. Nothing.
They also took my global entry card.
Anything I can do?
I’d be interested in hearing more. firstname.lastname@example.org